FMIP- 0999 Results
PARTICIPANTS: SFMSP agency and contractor laboratories
MATRIX: Filtered Water from the Everglades
ANALYTES: Total Mercury and Methylmercury
October 26, 1999
Dear Laboratory Director:
Attached are results from the recent Florida Mercury Intercomparison Study, FMIP-0999 (Attachment 1). A list of participating laboratories and associated contacts are included in Attachment 2.
A single surface water sample from site U3 in Water Conservation Area 2A of the Florida Everglades was used for this study. Paul Parks of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) Mercury Coordinator’s Office collected the sample on September 9. Using a Nytex filter on the suction side of the sampling pump, aliquots were collected into three new Nalgene LDPE 20L bottles with screw tops. Samples were stored in coolers without ice or any additional preservation.
Sample bottles were transported to Tallahassee and stored at room temperature until September 20, when they were moved to the FDEP Bureau of Laboratories’ mercury clean room. The FDEP laboratory staff conducted all subsequent sample handling. Two of the three 20L bottles were filtered through a 0.45 micron filter into a new Nalgene LDPE 50L bottle. Following filtration, this 50L bottle was equipped with a motorized stirrer with a stainless steel shaft and propeller to maintain homogeneity during subsampling of the aliquots.
Individual sample bottles were provided by the participating laboratories, except for Florida International University, for whom FDEP provided cleaned bottles. The sample bottles to be filled were placed in random order and filled sequentially by thirds. The samples bottles were placed in the coolers provided by the participating laboratories and shipped to each laboratory by overnight express. Each laboratory was notified of this shipment via telephone on the day of shipment. The laboratories were asked to analyze each of six replicates for total mercury and, if it was an analyte that the laboratory normally measured, methylmercury. The FDEP laboratory was aware that each sample to be tested was from a single water sample, although other laboratories were unaware of this.
Results as reported by each laboratory are presented in Table 1. Summary statistics for each laboratory are presented in Table 2. A graphical presentation of the results using median-quartile box-plots is included in Figures 1 and 2. If you have any questions about this study, please contact
Russel Frydenborg by email.
Sincerely,
/s/
Rebecca Northup, Environmental Manager
Environmental Assessment Section
Bureau of Laboratories
Division of Resource Assessment and Management
Attachments
Cc: Tom Atkeson/FDEP
Paul Parks/FDEP
Bill Coppenger/FDEP
Attachment 1
Table 1. Reported Analytical Results from Florida Mercury Intercomparison Study FMIP-0999.
|
Laboratory
|
Total Mercury
(ng/L)
|
Methylmercury
(ng/L)
|
| The Academy of Natural Sciences |
4.35
|
1.02
|
| |
4.46
|
1.09
|
| |
4.56
|
0.98
|
| |
4.56
|
1.08
|
| |
4.56
|
0.95
|
| |
4.53
|
1.03
|
| Brooks Rand |
4.92
|
0.71
|
| |
4.56
|
0.73
|
| |
4.43
|
0.77
|
| |
5.02
|
0.87
|
| |
4.68
|
0.72
|
| |
4.59
|
0.79
|
| Florida Dept of Environmental Protection |
4.82
|
0.77
|
| |
4.83
|
0.78
|
| |
4.85
|
0.75
|
| |
4.82
|
0.76
|
| |
4.88
|
0.76
|
| |
4.87
|
0.75
|
| Florida International University - SERP |
3.05
|
|
| |
2.81
|
|
| |
3.16
|
|
| |
2.84
|
|
| |
2.86
|
|
| |
2.82
|
|
| Frontier Geosciences |
5.02
|
1.03
|
| |
4.72
|
1.16
|
| |
4.68
|
1.27
|
| |
4.95
|
1.17
|
| |
4.88
|
1.12
|
| |
4.57
|
1.30
|
University of Michigan - Environmental
& Industrial Health |
4.22
|
|
| |
4.71
|
|
| |
4.57
|
|
| |
4.79
|
|
| |
4.37
|
|
| |
4.78
|
|
| USGS - Middleton, Wisconsin |
5.01
|
1.05
|
| |
4.48
|
1.05
|
| |
4.60
|
1.05
|
| |
4.89
|
1.18
|
| |
4.88
|
1.16
|
| |
4.99
|
1.19
|
Table 2. Summary Statistics
All Laboratories Combined
| Statistical Test |
Total Mercury
|
Methylmercury
|
| Minimum |
2.81
|
0.71
|
| 1st Quartile |
4.47
|
0.77
|
| Mean |
4.45
|
0.97
|
| Median |
4.64
|
1.03
|
| 3rd Quartile |
4.87
|
1.11
|
| Maximum |
5.02
|
1.30
|
| Total N |
42
|
30
|
| Std Dev. |
0.66
|
0.19
|
| SE Mean |
0.10
|
0.03
|
| Lower 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.24
|
0.90
|
| Upper 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.66
|
1.04
|
By Laboratory
The Academy of Natural Sciences
| Statistical Test |
Total Mercury
|
Methylmercury
|
| Minimum |
4.35
|
0.95
|
| 1st Quartile |
4.48
|
0.99
|
| Mean |
4.50
|
1.03
|
| Median |
4.55
|
1.03
|
| 3rd Quartile |
4.56
|
1.07
|
| Maximum |
4.56
|
1.09
|
| Total N |
6
|
6
|
| Std Dev. |
0.08
|
0.05
|
| SE Mean |
0.03
|
0.02
|
| Lower 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.41
|
0.97
|
| Upper 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.59
|
1.08
|
Brooks Rand
| Statistical Test |
Total Mercury
|
Methylmercury
|
| Minimum |
4.43
|
0.71
|
| 1st Quartile |
4.57
|
0.72
|
| Mean |
4.70
|
0.76
|
| Median |
4.64
|
0.75
|
| 3rd Quartile |
4.86
|
0.78
|
| Maximum |
5.02
|
0.87
|
| Total N |
6
|
6
|
| Std Dev. |
0.23
|
0.06
|
| SE Mean |
0.09
|
0.03
|
| Lower 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.46
|
0.70
|
| Upper 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.94
|
0.83
|
Florida Dept of Environmental Protection
| Statistical Test |
Total Mercury
|
Methylmercury
|
| Minimum |
4.82
|
0.75
|
| 1st Quartile |
4.82
|
0.75
|
| Mean |
4.85
|
0.76
|
| Median |
4.84
|
0.76
|
| 3rd Quartile |
4.87
|
0.77
|
| Maximum |
4.88
|
0.78
|
| Total N |
6
|
6
|
| Std Dev. |
0.03
|
0.01
|
| SE Mean |
0.01
|
0.00
|
| Lower 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.82
|
0.75
|
| Upper 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.87
|
0.77
|
Florida International University - SERP
| Statistical Test |
Total Mercury
|
Methylmercury
|
| Minimum |
2.81
|
|
| 1st Quartile |
2.83
|
|
| Mean |
2.92
|
|
| Median |
2.85
|
|
| 3rd Quartile |
3.00
|
|
| Maximum |
3.16
|
|
| Total N |
6
|
|
| Std Dev. |
0.15
|
|
| SE Mean |
0.06
|
|
| Lower 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
2.77
|
|
| Upper 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
3.08
|
|
Frontier Geosciences
| Statistical Test |
Total Mercury
|
Methylmercury
|
| Minimum |
4.57
|
1.03
|
| 1st Quartile |
4.69
|
1.13
|
| Mean |
4.80
|
1.18
|
| Median |
4.80
|
1.17
|
| 3rd Quartile |
4.93
|
1.25
|
| Maximum |
5.02
|
1.30
|
| Total N |
6
|
6
|
| Std Dev. |
0.17
|
0.10
|
| SE Mean |
0.07
|
0.04
|
Lower 95% Confidence Level
for the Mean |
4.62
|
1.07
|
Upper 95% Confidence Level
for the Mean |
4.99
|
1.28
|
University of Michigan - Environmental & Industrial Health
| Statistical Test |
Total Mercury
|
Methylmercury
|
| Minimum |
4.22
|
|
| 1st Quartile |
4.42
|
|
| Mean |
4.57
|
|
| Median |
4.64
|
|
| 3rd Quartile |
4.76
|
|
| Maximum |
4.79
|
|
| Total N |
6
|
|
| Std Dev. |
0.23
|
|
| SE Mean |
0.10
|
|
| Lower 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.33
|
|
| Upper 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.82
|
|
USGS Middleton, Wisconsin
| Statistical Test |
Total Mercury
|
Methylmercury
|
| Minimum |
4.48
|
1.05
|
| 1st Quartile |
4.67
|
1.05
|
| Mean |
4.81
|
1.11
|
| Median |
4.89
|
1.11
|
| 3rd Quartile |
4.97
|
1.18
|
| Maximum |
5.01
|
1.19
|
| Total N |
6
|
6
|
| Std Dev. |
0.22
|
0.07
|
| SE Mean |
0.09
|
0.03
|
| Lower 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
4.58
|
1.04
|
| Upper 95% Confidence Level for the Mean |
5.04
|
1.19
|
|
Figure 1. Median Boxplots of Total Mercury by Laboratory.

|
|
Figure 2. Median Boxplots of Methylmercury by Laboratory

|
Attachment 2: Laboratories Participating in the FMIP-0999 and Associated Contacts
Dr. Cynthia C. Gilmour, Assistant Curator
The Academy of Natural Sciences
Estuarine Research Center
10545 Mackall Road
St. Leonard, MD 20685
Dr. David Krabbenhoft, Research Hydrologist
Water Resources Division
US Geological Survey
8505 Research Way
Middleton, WI 53562
Dr. Jerry Keeler, Professor
Dept. of Environmental & Industrial Health
University of Michigan
109 Observatory St.
Ann Arbor, MI 48109-2029
Mr. Nicolas Bloom
Frontier Geosciences, Inc.
414 Pontius Avenue, North, Suite B
Seattle, WA 98109
Dr. Ronald D. Jones, Director
Southeast Environmental Research Program
Florida International University
University Park
Miami, FL 33199
Mr. Rick Manson
Brooks Rand, Ltd.
3950 6th Ave. N.W.
Seattle, WA 98107
Dr. Julio Arrecis, Manager
Bureau of Laboratories
Florida Department of Environmental Protection
2600 Blair Stone Rd. MS #6510
Tallahassee, FL 32399-2400
|